Merge pull request #40 from google/gbg/gatt-mtu

maintain the att mtu only at the connection level

bumble/gatt_client.py

@@ -163,7 +163,6 @@ class ProfileServiceProxy:
 class Client:
     def __init__(self, connection):
         self.connection               = connection
-        self.mtu                      = ATT_DEFAULT_MTU
         self.mtu_exchange_done        = False
         self.request_semaphore        = asyncio.Semaphore(1)
         self.pending_request          = None
@@ -217,7 +216,7 @@ class Client:
 
         # We can only send one request per connection
         if self.mtu_exchange_done:
-            return
+            return self.connection.att_mtu
 
         # Send the request
         self.mtu_exchange_done = True
@@ -230,8 +229,10 @@ class Client:
                 response
             )
 
-        self.mtu = max(ATT_DEFAULT_MTU, response.server_rx_mtu)
+        # Compute the final MTU
-        return self.mtu
+        self.connection.att_mtu = min(mtu, response.server_rx_mtu)
+
+        return self.connection.att_mtu
 
     def get_services_by_uuid(self, uuid):
         return [service for service in self.services if service.uuid == uuid]
@@ -629,7 +630,7 @@ class Client:
         # If the value is the max size for the MTU, try to read more unless the caller
         # specifically asked not to do that
         attribute_value = response.attribute_value
-        if not no_long_read and len(attribute_value) == self.mtu - 1:
+        if not no_long_read and len(attribute_value) == self.connection.att_mtu - 1:
             logger.debug('using READ BLOB to get the rest of the value')
             offset = len(attribute_value)
             while True:
@@ -651,7 +652,7 @@ class Client:
                 part = response.part_attribute_value
                 attribute_value += part
 
-                if len(part) < self.mtu - 1:
+                if len(part) < self.connection.att_mtu - 1:
                     break
 
                 offset += len(part)

bumble/gatt_server.py

@@ -40,6 +40,12 @@ from .gatt import *
 logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
 
 
+# -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
+# Constants
+# -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
+GATT_SERVER_DEFAULT_MAX_MTU = 517
+
+
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 # GATT Server
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
@@ -49,9 +55,8 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         self.device                = device
         self.attributes            = []  # Attributes, ordered by increasing handle values
         self.attributes_by_handle  = {}  # Map for fast attribute access by handle
-        self.max_mtu               = 23  # FIXME: 517  # The max MTU we're willing to negotiate
+        self.max_mtu               = GATT_SERVER_DEFAULT_MAX_MTU  # The max MTU we're willing to negotiate
         self.subscribers           = {}  # Map of subscriber states by connection handle and attribute handle
-        self.mtus                  = {}  # Map of ATT MTU values by connection handle
         self.indication_semaphores = defaultdict(lambda: asyncio.Semaphore(1))
         self.pending_confirmations = defaultdict(lambda: None)
 
@@ -188,9 +193,8 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         value = attribute.read_value(connection) if value is None else attribute.encode_value(value)
 
         # Truncate if needed
-        mtu = self.get_mtu(connection)
+        if len(value) > connection.att_mtu - 3:
-        if len(value) > mtu - 3:
+            value = value[:connection.att_mtu - 3]
-            value = value[:mtu - 3]
 
         # Notify
         notification = ATT_Handle_Value_Notification(
@@ -219,9 +223,8 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         value = attribute.read_value(connection) if value is None else attribute.encode_value(value)
 
         # Truncate if needed
-        mtu = self.get_mtu(connection)
+        if len(value) > connection.att_mtu - 3:
-        if len(value) > mtu - 3:
+            value = value[:connection.att_mtu - 3]
-            value = value[:mtu - 3]
 
         # Indicate
         indication = ATT_Handle_Value_Indication(
@@ -272,8 +275,6 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         return await self.notify_or_indicate_subscribers(True, attribute, value, force)
 
     def on_disconnection(self, connection):
-        if connection.handle in self.mtus:
-            del self.mtus[connection.handle]
         if connection.handle in self.subscribers:
             del self.subscribers[connection.handle]
         if connection.handle in self.indication_semaphores:
@@ -314,9 +315,6 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
                 # Just ignore
                 logger.warning(f'{color("--- Ignoring GATT Request from [0x{connection.handle:04X}]:", "red")}  {att_pdu}')
 
-    def get_mtu(self, connection):
-        return self.mtus.get(connection.handle, ATT_DEFAULT_MTU)
-
     #######################################################
     # ATT handlers
     #######################################################
@@ -336,12 +334,16 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         '''
         See Bluetooth spec Vol 3, Part F - 3.4.2.1 Exchange MTU Request
         '''
-        mtu = max(ATT_DEFAULT_MTU, min(self.max_mtu, request.client_rx_mtu))
+        self.send_response(connection, ATT_Exchange_MTU_Response(server_rx_mtu = self.max_mtu))
-        self.mtus[connection.handle] = mtu
+
-        self.send_response(connection, ATT_Exchange_MTU_Response(server_rx_mtu = mtu))
+        # Compute the final MTU
+        if request.client_rx_mtu >= ATT_DEFAULT_MTU:
+            mtu = min(self.max_mtu, request.client_rx_mtu)
 
             # Notify the device
             self.device.on_connection_att_mtu_update(connection.handle, mtu)
+        else:
+            logger.warning('invalid client_rx_mtu received, MTU not changed')
 
     def on_att_find_information_request(self, connection, request):
         '''
@@ -358,7 +360,7 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
             return
 
         # Build list of returned attributes
-        pdu_space_available = self.get_mtu(connection) - 2
+        pdu_space_available = connection.att_mtu - 2
         attributes = []
         uuid_size = 0
         for attribute in (
@@ -409,7 +411,7 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         '''
 
         # Build list of returned attributes
-        pdu_space_available = self.get_mtu(connection) - 2
+        pdu_space_available = connection.att_mtu - 2
         attributes = []
         for attribute in (
             attribute for attribute in self.attributes if
@@ -457,8 +459,7 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         See Bluetooth spec Vol 3, Part F - 3.4.4.1 Read By Type Request
         '''
 
-        mtu = self.get_mtu(connection)
+        pdu_space_available = connection.att_mtu - 2
-        pdu_space_available = mtu - 2
         attributes = []
         for attribute in (
             attribute for attribute in self.attributes if
@@ -471,7 +472,7 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
 
             # Check the attribute value size
             attribute_value = attribute.read_value(connection)
-            max_attribute_size = min(mtu - 4, 253)
+            max_attribute_size = min(connection.att_mtu - 4, 253)
             if len(attribute_value) > max_attribute_size:
                 # We need to truncate
                 attribute_value = attribute_value[:max_attribute_size]
@@ -511,7 +512,7 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         if attribute := self.get_attribute(request.attribute_handle):
             # TODO: check permissions
             value = attribute.read_value(connection)
-            value_size = min(self.get_mtu(connection) - 1, len(value))
+            value_size = min(connection.att_mtu - 1, len(value))
             response = ATT_Read_Response(
                 attribute_value = value[:value_size]
             )
@@ -530,7 +531,6 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
 
         if attribute := self.get_attribute(request.attribute_handle):
             # TODO: check permissions
-            mtu = self.get_mtu(connection)
             value = attribute.read_value(connection)
             if request.value_offset > len(value):
                 response = ATT_Error_Response(
@@ -538,14 +538,14 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
                     attribute_handle_in_error = request.attribute_handle,
                     error_code                = ATT_INVALID_OFFSET_ERROR
                 )
-            elif len(value) <= mtu - 1:
+            elif len(value) <= connection.att_mtu - 1:
                 response = ATT_Error_Response(
                     request_opcode_in_error   = request.op_code,
                     attribute_handle_in_error = request.attribute_handle,
                     error_code                = ATT_ATTRIBUTE_NOT_LONG_ERROR
                 )
             else:
-                part_size = min(mtu - 1, len(value) - request.value_offset)
+                part_size = min(connection.att_mtu - 1, len(value) - request.value_offset)
                 response = ATT_Read_Blob_Response(
                     part_attribute_value = value[request.value_offset:request.value_offset + part_size]
                 )
@@ -574,8 +574,7 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
             self.send_response(connection, response)
             return
 
-        mtu = self.get_mtu(connection)
+        pdu_space_available = connection.att_mtu - 2
-        pdu_space_available = mtu - 2
         attributes = []
         for attribute in (
             attribute for attribute in self.attributes if
@@ -586,7 +585,7 @@ class Server(EventEmitter):
         ):
             # Check the attribute value size
             attribute_value = attribute.read_value(connection)
-            max_attribute_size = min(mtu - 6, 251)
+            max_attribute_size = min(connection.att_mtu - 6, 251)
             if len(attribute_value) > max_attribute_size:
                 # We need to truncate
                 attribute_value = attribute_value[:max_attribute_size]

tests/gatt_test.py

@@ -131,7 +131,7 @@ async def test_characteristic_encoding():
         def decode_value(self, value_bytes):
             return value_bytes[0]
 
-    [client, server] = TwoDevices().devices
+    [client, server] = LinkedDevices().devices[:2]
 
     characteristic = Characteristic(
         'FDB159DB-036C-49E3-B3DB-6325AC750806',
@@ -306,14 +306,15 @@ def test_CharacteristicValue():
 
 
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
-class TwoDevices:
+class LinkedDevices:
     def __init__(self):
-        self.connections = [None, None]
+        self.connections = [None, None, None]
 
         self.link = LocalLink()
         self.controllers = [
             Controller('C1', link = self.link),
-            Controller('C2', link = self.link)
+            Controller('C2', link = self.link),
+            Controller('C3', link = self.link)
         ]
         self.devices = [
             Device(
@@ -321,12 +322,16 @@ class TwoDevices:
                 host    = Host(self.controllers[0], AsyncPipeSink(self.controllers[0]))
             ),
             Device(
-                address = 'F5:F4:F3:F2:F1:F0',
+                address = 'F1:F2:F3:F4:F5:F6',
                 host    = Host(self.controllers[1], AsyncPipeSink(self.controllers[1]))
+            ),
+            Device(
+                address = 'F2:F3:F4:F5:F6:F7',
+                host    = Host(self.controllers[2], AsyncPipeSink(self.controllers[2]))
             )
         ]
 
-        self.paired = [None, None]
+        self.paired = [None, None, None]
 
 
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
@@ -339,7 +344,7 @@ async def async_barrier():
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 @pytest.mark.asyncio
 async def test_read_write():
-    [client, server] = TwoDevices().devices
+    [client, server] = LinkedDevices().devices[:2]
 
     characteristic1 = Characteristic(
         'FDB159DB-036C-49E3-B3DB-6325AC750806',
@@ -416,7 +421,7 @@ async def test_read_write():
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 @pytest.mark.asyncio
 async def test_read_write2():
-    [client, server] = TwoDevices().devices
+    [client, server] = LinkedDevices().devices[:2]
 
     v = bytes([0x11, 0x22, 0x33, 0x44])
     characteristic1 = Characteristic(
@@ -466,7 +471,7 @@ async def test_read_write2():
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 @pytest.mark.asyncio
 async def test_subscribe_notify():
-    [client, server] = TwoDevices().devices
+    [client, server] = LinkedDevices().devices[:2]
 
     characteristic1 = Characteristic(
         'FDB159DB-036C-49E3-B3DB-6325AC750806',
@@ -631,12 +636,49 @@ async def test_subscribe_notify():
     assert not c3._called_2
 
 
+# -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
+@pytest.mark.asyncio
+async def test_mtu_exchange():
+    [d1, d2, d3] = LinkedDevices().devices[:3]
+
+    d3.gatt_server.max_mtu = 100
+
+    d3_connections = []
+    @d3.on('connection')
+    def on_d3_connection(connection):
+        d3_connections.append(connection)
+
+    await d1.power_on()
+    await d2.power_on()
+    await d3.power_on()
+
+    d1_connection = await d1.connect(d3.random_address)
+    assert len(d3_connections) == 1
+    assert d3_connections[0] is not None
+
+    d2_connection = await d2.connect(d3.random_address)
+    assert len(d3_connections) == 2
+    assert d3_connections[1] is not None
+
+    d1_peer = Peer(d1_connection)
+    d2_peer = Peer(d2_connection)
+
+    d1_client_mtu = await d1_peer.request_mtu(220)
+    assert d1_client_mtu == 100
+    assert d1_connection.att_mtu == 100
+
+    d2_client_mtu = await d2_peer.request_mtu(50)
+    assert d2_client_mtu == 50
+    assert d2_connection.att_mtu == 50
+
+
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 async def async_main():
     await test_read_write()
     await test_read_write2()
     await test_subscribe_notify()
     await test_characteristic_encoding()
+    await test_mtu_exchange()
 
 
 # -----------------------------------------------------------------------------